When truth hurts the wrong side: Court dismisses journalist Anora Sodiqova’s defamation claim
On 28 May the Shaykhantakhur District Civil Court (Tashkent) announced its decision in the case brought by journalist Anora Sodiqova against Mirsaid Haydarov, a government-affiliated blogger who writes under the pseudonym Mufasa.

Sodiqova had asked the court to protect her honor, dignity and business reputation, alleging that seven of Mufasa’s Facebook posts contained insults and defamatory statements about her.
How the proceedings unfolded
- The case was heard behind closed doors by Judge Dilnoza Shomatova.
- Three linguistic-psychological expert reports were submitted – one commissioned by Sodiqova and two ordered by the court itself. All three concluded that Haydarov’s posts contained language that demeaned and insulted the journalist.
- Despite these findings, the judge refused to admit the expert conclusions as evidence and rejected the claim in full.
- The defendant did not appear in court; his lawyers represented him.
“Throughout the hearing the judge repeatedly favored the other side,” Sodiqova told Kun.uz. “Our motions were denied, the proceedings were closed to the public, and in the end even the court-appointed experts were ignored. I have the impression that officials may freely insult journalists, while journalists are denied the right to defend themselves.”
The ruling obliges Sodiqova to pay a state fee of 750,000 UZS (about $60). She will file an appeal.
A stark contrast just days earlier
Only five days before, on 23 May, the Mirabad District Civil Court found human-rights defender Abdurakhmon Tashanov guilty of defaming two lecturers at Tashkent State University of Law over a single Facebook post titled “I pity you, gentlemen!”.
That court ordered him to issue a public apology and pay 50 million UZS (around $4,000) in moral damages.
Recommended
List of streets and intersections being repaired in Tashkent published
SOCIETY | 19:12 / 16.05.2024
Uzbekistan's flag flies high on Oceania's tallest volcano
SOCIETY | 17:54 / 15.05.2024
New tariffs to be introduced in Tashkent public transport
SOCIETY | 14:55 / 05.05.2023
Onix and Tracker cars withdrawn from sale
BUSINESS | 10:20 / 05.05.2023
Latest news
-
Uzbekistan to create centralized database of civil servants' social media accounts
POLITICS | 19:52
-
Tashkent-based startup launches Central Asia’s first national EV charging network with 3,000 locally made stations
SOCIETY | 18:28
-
Senate Chair Narbaeva and UNODC Rep discuss strengthening anti-trafficking and anti-corruption efforts
POLITICS | 18:26
-
Uzbekistan eyes green energy exports to Europe in regional push
POLITICS | 18:25
Related News

22:57 / 02.06.2025
Senator Erkaev: Justice system backsliding in Uzbekistan, public trust in judiciary declining

12:33 / 30.05.2025
‘I thought I was going to die’: Tashkent police torture suspects, attempt to frame them in drug case

17:16 / 22.04.2025
International lawyers advocate for fair trial, seek leniency for three citizens of Uzbekistan facing death penalty in UAE

14:57 / 13.03.2025